Skip to content

How we check the facts

  • Every number on this site comes with a source.

Where our numbers come from

  • We rank every source in one of five tiers.
  • A lower tier number means a stronger source.
  • When two sources disagree, we look first at the stronger one.
  1. Tier 1, official declarations. Kenya Gazette notices and the official declarations and results portals of the IEBC and the former Electoral Commission of Kenya (ECK).
  2. Tier 2, official records. IEBC result forms such as 34C, 35B, 36B and 37C. Also the Kriegler commission report, court judgments on Kenya Law, Hansard and reports from the Auditor General and the Controller of Budget. The Commission on Revenue Allocation and the Registrar of Political Parties belong here too.
  3. Tier 3, official websites. The Parliament of Kenya site, county government sites and Mzalendo.
  4. Tier 4, reference works. Wikipedia, used only to find the primary source it cites. We never cite it for a number on its own.
  5. Tier 5, major media. Nation, The Standard, The Star, Kenyans.co.ke, Citizen, KBC and Business Daily.

The two-source rule

  • We call a fact verified only when two independent sources agree and at least one of them is in tier 1 or tier 2.
  • One official source on its own is not enough to earn that label.
  • We never invent a number, a date or a name.
  • If we cannot find it, we leave the field empty and say why.

What the labels mean

  • Each result and profile carries one of four labels.
  • Verified. Two independent sources agree. One of them is official.
  • One official source. The figure comes from a single tier 1 or tier 2 source. We have not yet found a second.
  • Sources disagree. Our sources give different figures. We show what each one says and do not pick one.
  • Not yet verified. Some figures come only from news outlets or reference sources, even when the winner’s figure is official. Treat them with care.

Checking the arithmetic

  • Before a result goes live, our importer runs two checks on it.
  • First, the votes for all candidates must add up to the total valid votes.
  • Second, turnout cannot be higher than the number of registered voters.
  • When a result fails either check, we do not quietly fix it.
  • We mark the race as one where the sources disagree and list the problem on the result page.
  • That way you can see the gap and judge it for yourself.
  • Some sources give votes but no share. We then divide by the valid total.
  • If that total is missing we divide by the sum of every candidate’s votes as long as all of their figures are on file.
  • A winner-only race shows no share.
  • Some vote counts are not on file because the official tally form was not found online.
  • We never guess them.
  • The result table marks each one as not yet verified until an official source gives the figure.

Controversies, audits and court cases

  • Profiles can include controversies, audit findings and court cases.
  • An editor reviews each one before we publish it.
  • We state the legal status plainly: allegation, charged, acquitted, convicted, cleared or ongoing.
  • An allegation is always labelled as an allegation.
  • Where the person has responded in public, we print that response next to the claim.

Your right of reply

  • If you are named in a controversy, you can send us your response.
  • An editor checks it and then publishes it next to the claim.
  • Anyone can also report an error on any page.
  • When we correct a page, we note the correction and its date on that page.
  • Use the corrections and replies form.

Photos

  • We only use photos from Wikimedia Commons, the Parliament of Kenya website or an official county website.
  • For Commons photos we record the licence and credit the author.
  • We do not take photos from news sites or social media.
  • When we have no photo that meets this rule, the profile shows the person’s initials instead.

What the 2007 results can tell you

  • The 2007 election was followed by violence that left more than 1,000 people dead.
  • A commission led by South African judge Johann Kriegler then reviewed how the election was run.
  • Its 2008 report found the whole process so flawed that the results could not be trusted.
  • In its words, “The results are irretrievably polluted.”
  • We still publish the 2007 figures because they are the official record.
  • They show who the ECK declared as winners and what the official forms said.
  • They cannot tell you with confidence how people voted, in the presidential race or in the MP races.
  • Read every 2007 figure with the Kriegler findings in mind.
  • Many constituency boundaries also changed in 2012.
  • A 2007 seat does not always match a seat that exists today.